hide

The Donner Party (2009 film)

Article
Talk

Tools

Appearancehide

Text

SmallStandardLarge

Width

StandardWide

Color (beta)

AutomaticLightDark

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

The Donner Party (2009)
Theatrical release poster
Directed by	Terrence Martin
Screenplay by	Terrence Martin
Produced by	Mark Costa Ted Meyer John Emerson Moore
Starring	Crispin Glover Clayne Crawford Mark Boone Junior Christian Kane
Cinematography	Seamus Tierney
Edited by	Richard Conkling John Emerson Moore
Music by	Eimear Noone
Production company	Anacapa Entertainment
Distributed by	First Look International
Release date	October 23, 2009 (Austin Film Festival)
Running time	95 minutes
Country	United States
Language	English

The Donner Party is a 2009 American period Western drama film written and directed by Terrence Martin (credited as T.J. Martin), and starring Crispin Glover, Clayne Crawford, Michele Santopietro, Mark Boone Junior, and Christian Kane. It is based on the true story of the Donner Party, an 1840s westward traveling group of settlers headed for California. Becoming snowbound in the Sierra Nevada mountains, with food increasingly scarce, a small group calling themselves “The Forlorn Hope” turned to cannibalism. The Forlorn was the working title for the film.^[1]

Plot

The film opens with text explaining who the Donner Party was and how they ended up in the terrible situation of passing the cutoff. It then proceeds to a dramatization largely following the exploits of main character William Foster (Crispin Glover) during the attempt to cross the Sierra Nevada mountains and his group that would be later known as “The Forlorn Hope” whilst seeking rescue for the broader Donner Party (the film chooses to focus on a select few characters, while in the real-life background the Donner-Reed Party considered of a fairly large group of multiple families). The film takes several artistic liberties with the true story basis, and combines multiple real-life historic figures from the Donner-Reed Party into these characters.

William Foster is bothered by the deterioration he sees in the makeshift camps built by the Donner Party, the increasing worry of the women and children in the camps, and a recent death which concludes in a burial while onlookers grieve, distraught. He prays frequently, hoping that devotion to God will provide some hope for his fellow pioneers, and as things continue to get worse and the snowfall builds, he opts to go on ahead and seek aid in rescue. Foster finds himself consistently at odds with fellow pioneer William Eddy (Clayne Crawford), and the group begins to bicker as rations grow more scarce. Violence ensues, including a fight during which a person is nearly stabbed to death, and when starvation sets in, the group decides to draw straws to decide which man will be sacrificed (Jay Fosdick (Cary Wayne Moore) refuses to participate in the “game”). Foster ends up executing fellow pioneer Milt McCutchen (Jack Kyle) with a gunshot wound to the back of the head after the man ends up drawing the shortest straw.

Fosdick is criticized for failing to add any ration to the shared pot of food that the group is collecting, and he in turn chastizes Foster for his callousness in executing McCutchen, to which Foster remarks, “everyone is to contribute to the pot equally”. Eddy later has disturbing delusions in his sleep of his wife, Eleanor (Jamie Anne Allman) standing in the snow in a white dress, totally emaciated, holding a deceased infant’s corpse as it drips with blood. Upon awakening, he discovers that the group’s Native American guide, Luis (John A. Lorenz), whom Eddy has been secretly protecting, has fled into the forest, with Foster looking for him after suspecting him of misleading the group. Eddy holds a crazed Foster at gunpoint, but is unable to shoot the man. Foster finds Luis and bludgeons him to death before eviscerating his corpse off-screen; meanwhile Eddy collapses in the snow from illness due to starvation, and his wife sneaks him meat.

Fosdick severely lacerates his leg in a sudden fall, and fearing that Foster will murder the man in his weakened state, his wife, Ann Fosdick (Catherine Black) savagely asserts that he is fine. Foster becomes extremely bloodthirsty, and it is implied that he feeds his group the butchered corpse of Luis, as they all gnaw in horror upon pieces of bizarre-looking meat. Ann and Jay Fosdick find that whenever Ann isn’t present, Foster is sneaking up behind Jay with strange offers to put him out of his misery due to his injured leg. Ann chases Foster off, and as Foster saunters away, he is seen holding a knife in his hand. It is unclear whether these disturbing sights are real, or merely paranoid delusions among the group. As the group continues to starve and freeze to death, Foster is left weak and shivering under blankets, and to his surprise, Eddy acts as an ally and offers to go seek rescue with the aid of fellow pioneer Mary Graves (Alison Haislip). Instead of finding help, however, Eddy sneaks back the next morning with Mary and the pair shoot Jay Fosdick to death, leaving Ann Fosdick in hysterics. Eddy and Mary rip open Jay’s abdomen, remove his intestines and liver, and begin eating these internal organs while a horrified Ann flees. She comes upon a freezing Foster, who comforts her and is revealed to have been the more trustworthy and sane of the group after all, in comparison with Eddy, who decides to continue alone on the journey to California, leaving Mary behind to die. As Foster, his wife and the remaining survivors later gather together before a solemn campfire, Amanda McCutchen (Michele Santopietro), (the wife of the earlier-executed Milt McCutchen), proceeds to secretly arm Ann Fosdick with a shotgun. Catching Foster off guard and unaware, Ann procedures to execute him with a gunshot wound to the face. The film ends with William Eddy collapsing in the snow, presumably near his destination as two men are shown discovering his fallen body, the sound of his heart still beating as he is finally rescued. The camera slowly pans out, with captioning on the screen indicating that Eddy’s wife and son (who remained behind in Illinois) had died sometime over the winter; of the “Forlorn Hope” group, only 5 survived.

Cast

Crispin Glover as William Foster
Clayne Crawford as William Eddy
Michele Santopietro as Amanda McCutchen
Mark Boone Junior as Franklin Graves
Christian Kane as Charles Stanton
Crispian Belfrage as Patrick Dolan
Catherine Black as Ann Fosdick
Jamie Anne Allman as Eleanor Eddy
Jack Kyle as Milt McCutchen
Cary Wayne as Jay Fosdick
Alison Haislip as Mary Graves
Mara LaFontaine as Sarah Foster
John A. Lorenz as Luis

Production

As well as being Martin’s directorial debut, The Donner Party was production company Anacapa Entertainment’s first feature film.^[2] It premiered at the Austin Film Festival on October 23, 2009,^[3] Its DVD release was three months later on January 26. Shooting was swift, with principal photography at the Donner Pass, California taking only 12 days.^[4]^[5] Originally, the work had a higher budget, with greater use of child stars and a longer shooting schedule. However, the original production company pulled funding for the project, so several changes were made. The title change was a marketing choice by the distributor.^[6]

The soundtrack was done by the Aspiro Choir under Mary Amond O’Brien.^{[citation needed]}

Release

The film was released on DVD by First Look Pictures on January 26, 2010. It was later re-released by Millennium Entertainment on October 20, 2015, as a part of its 12 Movie Sci-Fi Pack.^[7]

Reception

The website Bloody Good Horror gave the film an unfavorable review, describing Crispin Glover’s performance as boring and the story dull. “Simply put, ‘The Donner Party’ is a plodding chore of a movie to watch. It’s a history professor’s voiceover away from being indistinguishable from your average History Channel reenactment.”^[8]

Dread Central awarded the film a score of three out of five, commending Glover and Boone Junior’s performances, writing: “T.J. Martin’s cinematic version of this dreadful episode in American history is carried off rather well although, as always seems to be the case with films based on historical events, a lot of what transpires in the film never happened, which IS annoying to history buffs like myself. At least the film was shot during the winter in the Donner Pass near Truckee, California, which helped with the verisimilitude.”^[9] Horror News.Net gave the film a positive review, writing, “Overall “The Donner Party” was a nice change from the hard core horror films that I usually watch. I have a feeling it will be shown in a lot of high school history classes in the future as there is really nothing offensive that would make it inappropriate for younger viewers. If you are in the mood for something a little different I suggest you give it a try. I also recommend that you have something to eat on hand while watching it as I was starving by the time I was done watching it. Then again, maybe I have issues.”^[10]

References

Voeller, Carey R. (2009). “‘A man is a fool who prefers poor California beef to human flesh’: (Re)Definitions of Masculinity in Nineteenth-Century US Donner Party Literature”. Western American Literature. 44 (3): 219. doi:10.1353/wal.0.0045.
“Production Begins on Anacapa Entertainment ‘The Forlorn.'” Marketwire (press release). April 26, 2008. (via Lexis-Nexis)
Oh, Steph. “Austin Film Festival Line-Up Released”. Austinist. September 25, 2009 (via Lexis-Nexis).
Brown, Jenn. “AFF Review: The Donner Party“. Slackerwood. November 2, 2009. Retrieved March 13, 2010.
“The Donner Party“. First Look Studios. Retrieved March 13, 2010.
Johnson, Kristin. “Director responds“. February 8, 2010. Donner Blog. Retrieved March 16, 2010.
“The Donner Party (2009) – T.J. Martin”. Allmovie.com. AllMovie. Retrieved 1 November 2017.
“The Donner Party (Movie Review)”. bloodygoodhorror.com. 25 January 2010. Retrieved 15 February 2021.
“Donner Party, The (2009) – Dread Central”. Dread Central.com. thebellefromhell. 8 February 2010. Retrieved 1 November 2017.
“Film Review: The Donner Party (2009)”. HorrorNews.net. Horror News. 15 January 2011. Retrieved 1 November 2017.

External links

The Donner Party at IMDb
The Donner Party at Rotten Tomatoes

Categories:

56thst.com

Articles, books and commentary by Joel Snell

THE DONNER PARTY

Contents