CHI-SQUARED/ FISHER&IRWIN
- Skip to Article Content
- Skip to Article Information
Search withinThis JournalAnywhere
- Search term
Login / Register
Research Article
Chi-squared and Fisher–Irwin tests of two-by-two tables with small sample recommendations
First published: 21 February 2007
Citations: 664
Abstract
Two-by-two tables commonly arise in comparative trials and cross-sectional studies. In medical studies, two-by-two tables may have a small sample size due to the rarity of a condition, or to limited resources. Current recommendations on the appropriate statistical test mostly specify the chi-squared test for tables where the minimum expected number is at least 5 (following Fisher and Cochran), and otherwise the Fisher–Irwin test; but there is disagreement on which versions of the chi-squared and Fisher–Irwin tests should be used. A further uncertainty is that, according to Cochran, the number 5 was chosen arbitrarily. Computer-intensive techniques were used in this study to compare seven two-sided tests of two-by-two tables in terms of their Type I errors. The tests were K. Pearson’s and Yates’s chi-squared tests and the ‘N−1’ chi-squared test (first proposed by E. Pearson), together with four versions of the Fisher–Irwin test (including two mid-P versions). The optimum test policy was found to be analysis by the ‘N−1’ chi-squared test when the minimum expected number is at least 1, and otherwise, by the Fisher–Irwin test by Irwin’s rule (taking the total probability of tables in either tail that are as likely as, or less likely than the one observed). This policy was found to have increased power compared to Cochran’s recommendations. Copyright © 2007 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
REFERENCES
Citing Literature
30 August 2007
Pages 3661-3675
Recommended
- A Comparison of the Three Conditional Exact Tests in Two‐way Contingency Tables Using the Unconditional Exact PowerSeung-Ho Kang, Su-Jin KimBiometrical Journal
- Contingency Tables, Chi-Squared Test, and Fisher’s Exact TestStatistics in Nutrition and Dietetics, [1]
- Nonparametric Two‐Sample TestsStatistics in Nutrition and Dietetics, [1]
- Fisher’s Exact TestGraham J. G. UptonJournal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series A (Statistics in Society)
Additional links
About Wiley Online Library
- Privacy Policy
- Terms of Use
- About Cookies
- Manage Cookies
- Accessibility
- Wiley Research DE&I Statement and Publishing Policies
- Developing World Access
Help & Support
Opportunities
Connect with Wiley
Copyright © 1999-2025 John Wiley & Sons, Inc or related companies. All rights reserved, including rights for text and data mining and training of artificial intelligence technologies or similar technologies.
