GUNS, GERMS, AND STEEL
Log InSign Up
Outlinekeyboard_arrow_down
Download Free PDF
Guns, Germs And Steel: The Fate of Human Societies. Jared Diamond. New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 1997. pp.494.
yalemzewd DessiedescriptionView full PDFdownloadDownload PDFformat_quoteCitebookmarkSave to LibraryshareShare
download
248
downloads
visibility
1,415 views
description
3 pagesclose
Sign up for access to the world’s latest research
Sign up for freearrow_forward
checkGet notified about relevant papers
checkSave papers to use in your research
checkJoin the discussion with peers
checkTrack your impact
Abstract
In his book Guns, Germs, and Steel, the author irradiates so many intricate aspects of the fates of human societies. The book attempts to answer the question posed by Guinea’s charismatic leader, Yali: why did human development proceed at such different rates on different continents? And to answer Yali’s quest, the book is thematically organized into four parts and nineteen chapters.descriptionSee full PDFdownloadDownload PDF
Related papers
Eoghan Fallon 87497 Guns, Germs and Steel
Jared Diamond’s ‘Guns, Germs and Steel’ is a fantastic read that epitomises the popular science books that are widely read today but also nicely summarises the last 13,000 years of human history and progress. Diamond, a biologist who has worked extensively in New Guinea, turned to the question of how we got to here and why some people have been more successful than others through his field work on that island. After being asked by a local politician, Yali, why white people had all the ‘cargo’ or goods worth something while the blacks of the island had very little in comparison, he got to thinking what factors paved the way for European dominance. As he asserts in his preface he attempts to avoid Eurocentrism but as his critics and I found he must frequently refer to that continent to gain understanding of the others. His theory on how the environment and geography shaped human fortunes are remarkably interesting as well as his unique combination of history, biology, ecology and linguistics.
downloadDownload free PDFView PDFchevron_right
2014
downloadDownload free PDFView PDFchevron_right
The Sociology of ‘Developing Societies’: Problems of Teaching and Definition
The Sociological Review, 1977
downloadDownload free PDFView PDFchevron_right
Anthropology of Development (ANTH 212)
In this course, we divide the long history of development into 3 sections. First, we look to how the center of the world trade system shifted from Asia and the Mideast to Europe. It was not until the 16th century that it became clear that European powers were gaining the upper hand in the control of energy and resources around the world. This shift was accompanied by a flourishing of social sciences that explained European hegemony in terms of evolution and progress, as well as by a peculiar ethos that celebrated the accumulation of wealth. Second, an internationalist system was set in place after World War II that structured the flow of money and credit with the expressed purpose of encouraging economic growth in targeted countries. Finally, during the 1980s, development became characterized, on one hand, by a proliferation of networks of non-governmental organizations, and on the other, by concerns over humanitarian aid, local autonomy, the environment, health and security.
downloadDownload free PDFView PDFchevron_right
downloadDownload free PDFView PDFchevron_right
A reassessment of civilization
Metascience
Your article is protected by copyright and all rights are held exclusively by Springer Nature B.V.. This e-offprint is for personal use only and shall not be self-archived in electronic repositories. If you wish to self-archive your article, please use the accepted manuscript version for posting on your own website. You may further deposit the accepted manuscript version in any repository, provided it is only made publicly available 12 months after official publication or later and provided acknowledgement is given to the original source of publication and a link is inserted to the published article on Springer’s website. The link must be accompanied by the following text: “The final publication is available at link.springer.com”.
downloadDownload free PDFView PDFchevron_right
A Brief History of Development
2020
This paper presents a brief history of developing countries from 1945 to 2020. These countries have experienced major economic and social changes since decolonization, which began almost immediately after World War II. The leaders of these newly independent countries were generally of the view then that sovereignty called for industrialization and education, and that it would be sufficient to reach quickly the level of development of rich countries. Most of these countries adopted import-substituting industrialization policies. In the 1960s, OECD governments set up institutions to provide assistance and cooperation, and aid from rich to poorer countries increased massively. For a while, economic growth was satisfactory and the mood in developing countries was euphoric. In the course of a generation, agrarian societies were transformed into industrialized and urbanized societies. But the optimism of the 1950s and 1960s was masking negative trends. The trade balance worsened, leading to the need for financial loans, and the external debt problem of developing countries became extremely serious in the late 1970s. Agricultural productivity and food supply were also an issue, as well as the population explosion—resulting from death rate declines due to social progress while birth rates remained high—which was mortgaging future development. Overall, results fell far short of national economic aspirations. The “new world order” collapsed with the US abandonment of the Gold-Dollar Standard in 1971 and the oil shocks, while new technological innovation and the growth of financial markets led to a new era of triumphant globalization. Aid and capital transfers from rich to poor countries, assorted with harsh conditionality, prevented the collapse of living standards in developing countries. The “Washington Consensus,” perhaps unfairly, came to stand for a package of measures aimed largely at getting the government out of the economy. Poverty considerations were put aside during these adjustment years. The neoliberal perspective that dominated the 1980s considered that economic growth was all that really mattered for welfare to improve, and that poverty and inequality would take care of themselves. Proponents of that view downplayed distribution and poverty, and insisted on re-establishing market mechanisms to promote economic growth. In terms of economic wellbeing and living standard improvements, between 1945 and 1979, progress was very slow, except in a few countries. Relative poverty did not decline very fast, in large part because of population growth and very slow increase in agricultural productivity (until around 1965) in developing countries. In the post-adjustment period, after the 1980s, enormous social progress was achieved. Poverty in the world declined from 52% of developing world population in 1980 to 17% in 2011, thanks largely to China. However progress has been extremely uneven: in East Asia, poverty declined from 77% to 8% but in Sub-Saharan Africa from 51% to 47% only. Inequality across individuals fell, largely because of the sharp increase in income in China and India, but international inequality in income has increased across nations. Health inequalities were, and still are, gigantic. Between 1990 and 2020, developing countries have been buffeted by economic and financial crises—and have had to adapt to globalization. Trade liberalization boosted trade flows at rates far faster than global income growth. The result is that, today, unskilled workers in the West are the ones being “displaced” by the workers from China and a few emerging economies. In many low income countries, entire populations are excluded from the process of globalization, and therefore from its benefits. Overall, since 1945, even though the world has experienced widespread poverty and tragic displacements forced upon people by globalization, it can be said that better welfare outcomes and more stability and peace have been produced during periods of globalization than during inward-turning periods.
downloadDownload free PDFView PDFchevron_right
Journalof Developing Societies
2010
A number of concepts and measurement procedures have been proposed to describe the development-level differences among nations. This paper reviews them and examines their interrelationships. Fifteen variables and their intercorrelations are discussed. Of these, 10 were deemed acceptable on theoretical and empirical grounds for factor analysis. Two strong, orthogonal factors were found to meet the conventional criteria. They were labeled domestic development (DD) and authority (A). DD loads most on life expectancy, infant mortality (negative), lo~ GNP/c, and popUlation growth rate (negative). A loads most on logn population, Wallerstein's "core-periphery," and Rossem's "prominence." Thus the two factors reflect two very different phenomena. DD expresses the meaning of development commonly held by economic planners. A expresses the relative power of orie nation to exert influence on another, with total population and core status serving as resources by whic…
downloadDownload free PDFView PDFchevron_right
THE END OF DEVELOPMENT: A global history of poverty and prosperity
2017
Why did some countries grow rich while others remained poor? Tracing the long arc of human history from hunter gatherer societies to the early twenty first century, Andrew Brooks rejects popular explanations for the divergence of nations. This accessible and illuminating volume shows how the wealth of ‘the West’ and poverty of ‘the rest’ stem not from environmental factors or some unique European cultural, social or technological qualities, but from the expansion of colonialism and the rise of America. Brooks puts the case that international inequality was moulded by capitalist development over the last 500 years. The End of Development provides a compelling account of how human history unfolded differently in varied regions of the world. Brooks argues that we must now seize the opportunity afforded by today’s changing economic geography to transform attitudes towards inequality and to develop radical new approaches to addressing global poverty, as the alternative is to accept that impoverishment is somehow part of the natural order of things.
downloadDownload free PDFView PDFchevron_right
How Much Human Sacrifice is Sufficient: Estimating the Transhistorical Development of Africa
Large scale wars and deaths cannot be ruled out of explanations of the rise of the West and the emergence of political centralization which is pertinent for “development” today. Yet for Africa this has tended to remain at literary levels of analysis. This represents a proposal for a trans-historical and trans-existential analysis of development. It proposes the estimation of the number of war-related deaths which Africa would have needed to sacrifice in order to attain Eurasian levels to make “development” more rapid in contemporary times.
downloadDownload free PDFView PDFchevron_right
Guns, Germs And Steel: The Fate of Human Societies. Jared Diamond. New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 1997. pp.494. By: Yalemzewd Dessie; Email: yalemzewddessie@gmail.com Phone No: +251-910691566 Page 1 Numerous literary works document the racial struggle designed to assert white inborn supremacy over Africans, Asians, and Americans. Meanwhile, they were accompanied by a battle to ensure the legacies of capitalism, imperialism, and slavery. 1 But American geographer, historian, and ornithologist Jared Diamond made flamboyant attempts to disprove the aforementioned assertions of racial superiority. Jared Diamond has authored well-known popular science books such as The Third Chimpanzee, Collapse, The World Until Yesterday, Upheaval, and Guns, Germs, and Steel. Among his fathomable works, the Pulitzer Prize-winning “Guns, Germs, and Steel,” which was published in 1997, is the focus of this review. In his book Guns, Germs, and Steel, the author irradiates so many intricate aspects of the fates of human societies. The book attempts to answer the question posed by Guinea’s charismatic leader, Yali: why did human development proceed at such different rates on different continents? And to answer Yali’s quest, the book is thematically organized into four parts and nineteen chapters. The book’s first section, “From Eden to Cajamarca,” is divided into three chapters. This section presents a journey through human evolution and history, tracing the spread of humans from Africa to other continents. Additionally, it examines the effects of continental environments on human history over the past 13,000 years. The capture of the last independent Inca emperor, Atahualpa, by Francisco Pizarro and his small band of conquistadores in Cajamarca, described as the most dramatic encounter in history, is also presented in this section. The book’s second part, organized into seven chapters, is entitled “The Rise and Spread of Food Production.” Overall, the section thus focuses on the ultimate causes of Pizarro’s triumph. It explores the various factors driving the shift from the hunter-gatherer lifestyle to food production. Additionally, it looks at the immediate factors behind Europe’s conquest of Native Americans, such as Spanish germs, horses, literacy, political organization, and technology. The hard part of the section is identifying the ultimate causes leading to them and the actual outcome. The third part of the book, which is divided into four chapters, benevolences the connections between ultimate and proximate causes, such as the progression of guns, germs, and steel production, the trait of dense human populations, the rise of food production, and the invention of writing. Hence, the section exemplifies how food production enabled farmers to support full-time craft specialists, politicians, chiefs, kings, and bureaucrats, which were essential for governing large and populous domains. The political environment of hunter-gatherers’ was limited to their territory and alliances, leading to the rise of chiefs, kings, and bureaucrats. The book’s last section is organized into five chapters entitled “Around the World.” This part, it looks at the histories of Australia and New Guinea, two countries whose food production did not grow on their own. The integrated developments in Australia and New Guinea are also presented from the standpoint of the entire region, which includes the East Asian mainland and Pacific islands. Finally, it elaborates on the differences between Sub-Saharan Africa and the Americas in terms of domesticable plants and animals, bacteria, the duration of human settlement, the orientation of the continental axes, and ecological barriers. So many new arguments make Jared Diamond’s book dazzling. His first point is what is known as “geographic determinism.” He made an eye-opening argument that the dramatic disparities in the long-term histories of the various peoples of different continents were not caused by inherent
Guns, Germs And Steel: The Fate of Human Societies. Jared Diamond. New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 1997. pp.494. By: Yalemzewd Dessie; Email: yalemzewddessie@gmail.com Phone No: +251-910691566 Page 2 distinctions in the peoples themselves. Instead, geographical locations have influenced various world developments. Among the authors’ most reliable examples are the Moriori and Maori peoples of New Zealand, peoples of the same race as siblings from Polynesia but whose geographic differences have led to different economic lifestyles. According to him, the difference in IQ between the individuals living in the same country is caused by differences in geographic locations, their social environment, and access to technology and education. (pp.22-25) Jared Diamond also makes the astounding claim that “necessity is the mother of invention.” He asserted that high population density, disease, technology, political organizations, and other elements of power were all caused by following the domestication of plants and animals. According to Diamond, those who coincidentally inherited or created food products and technologies due to their geographic location were able to engulf those who were less geographically endowed. (p.386) Another interesting argument by Jared Diamond is the basis of European imperialism: they take advantage of the metaphors, “first come, first served” and “haves over have notes.” Accordingly, Europeans took advantage of military technology based on guns, steel weapons, and horses; infectious germs; maritime technology; and centralized political organization more than the other continents. For instance, the author notes that smallpox, measles, influenza, typhus, bubonic plague, and other infectious diseases made it easier for Eurasia to annex regions such as the Aztecs, pre- Colombian Native Americans, Tonga, Hawaii, and the Pacific Islands. (p.76) Jared Diamond also summed up the “universality of human creativity.” Accordingly, whatever the difference in geography as well as the environment, every human society developed its own creativity in different aspects and diffused it. This is evidenced in Sumerian and Mesoamerican written developments. Therefore, geography also affects written dissemination. (p.222) According to Jared Diamond, the immediate cause of the inequities in the modern world is the technological and political balkanization that began about the year 1500 AD. Surprisingly, he tried to foresee the future developments of historical science. (p. 421) Personally, I don’t think Jared Diamond is right to say that it is geography as a whole that determines human history. Hence, he refused to acknowledge the considerable human or artificial influences on geography and the environment. Regarding the final destination of societies, Jared Diamond refrained from conveying the intention behind those societies that did not adopt or diffuse new crops, livestock, and technologies. (p.154) Jared Diamond knowingly or unknowingly overlooked the ancient Ethiopian domestication of plants such as teff, nug, enset, and dagussa. (p. 100, 101, 126). In addition, in his debate about the origin of animal pathogens and their dissemination from Eurasia to the rest of the continents, he also refrained from presenting the case of smallpox epidemics in Ethiopia and South Arabia. In fact, Arab traditions and some literary works attest to an outbreak of smallpox among Aksumite soldiers around 370 AD in Saudi Arabia. 2 Moreover, I have doubts about the writer’s generalization of the people of areas with head starts on food production, thereby gaining a head start on the path leading towards guns, germs, and steel. (p.103) And also, his generalization of geography merely affects the fate of human civilization. Hence, to me, his generalization may be nullified by the case of the Nile River Valley civilization and culture of Egypt and Ethiopia. Hence, the above-mentioned civilization has a long history of
Guns, Germs And Steel: The Fate of Human Societies. Jared Diamond. New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 1997. pp.494. By: Yalemzewd Dessie; Email: yalemzewddessie@gmail.com Phone No: +251-910691566 Page 3 domestication of plants and animals with suitable geography, but they did not develop guns, germs, and steel. In addition, there are some technical irregularities related to using generic terms and word selections, like the writer simultaneously using the term colonialism for those native peoples and newcomers who control the land. It is better to say colony as well as a settler for the first one. Lastly, Jared Diamond’s knowledge, experience, and use of interdisciplinary sciences, different figures, and illustrations enabled his work to exemplify the nature of the entire world’s civilization, which was shaped and reshaped by lopsided outcomes. And I agreed with his quote: “History followed different courses for different peoples because of differences among people’s environments, not because of biological differences among people themselves.” (p. 25) 1 Rutledge M. Dennis, “Social Darwinism, Scientific Racism, and the Metaphysics of Race,” The Journal of Negro Education , Summer, 1995, Vol. 64, No. 3, Myths and Realities: African Americans and the Measurement of Human Abilities (Summer, 1995), 243-252; and see also Hunt (Eds.), “Impacts of racism on White Americans,” Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, 77-85. 2 Wallis Budge, A History of Ethiopia: Nubia and Abyssinia, (Rutledge, Vol. I, 1928), 268; Alemu Haile, Ye Ityopiya Tarik: Yatsie Zera Yacob ena Yatsie Bede Maryam Zena Mewal Ke Geez wede Amaregna Yetteregome, Addis Ababa: Sirak Asatami Dirjet, 2000, 84-89; and see also Richard Pankhurst, “Old-Time Ethiopian Cures for Syphilis, Seventeenth to Twentieth Centuries.” Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences, Vol. 30, No.3 (JULY 1975), 199-216. About the author
![]()
Debre Markos University, Department MemberaddFollowmailMessage
God bless Ethiopian and its peoples
Papers
9
Followers
136View all papers from yalemzewd Dessiearrow_forward
Related papers
GUNS, GERMS AND STEEL THE FATES OF HUMAN SOCIETIES
downloadDownload free PDFView PDFchevron_right
Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies (Book Review)
2011
downloadDownload free PDFView PDFchevron_right
In his book guns, germs and steel: the fate of human society, Professor Jared Diamond explores the origin of human inequality from the perspective of different continental environments. In different stages of history, the reasons for the gap in the comprehensive development level of different regions in the world are different. By clarifying the causes of human inequality, we can draw inspiration to deal with the current situation of the world and make due contributions to the development of the world community. Knowing the causes of human inequality, Professor Diamond believes that the answer needs to be found from the source of human existence. Before the disparity, people around the world lived in much the same way. Rousseau, in On the Origins and Foundations of Human Inequality, points out that humans of this period were: “Lonely, idle, and often dangerous barbarians… Always sleep when you’re not thinking. ” [1] The barbarians are basically in a state of isolation, and the level of development between the regions is almost non-existent in a natural state, during which time the regions are in a state of peace. With the change of the geographical environment in which human beings are living, the gap between the level of development of various regions is beginning to emerge. Professor Diamond believes that in the primitive period, agriculture, animal husbandry is very important to the development of human inequality, because of geographical location, living environment differences, often the most high-yielding ethnic groups are most vulnerable to high-yield farmers, thus accelerating the progress of their own people. As early as 1845, Marx pointed out in his book, “In order to live, the first need to eat, drink and wear and other things. Thus the first historical activity is the production of information to meet these needs, i.e. the production of material life itself.” [2] From the perspective of labor, this paper discusses the premise of the historical development of human society, namely, the material life of production itself, and how the gap between the level of development between regions evolves in the course of labor. In his writings, Professor Diamond thinks the factors that arise from the inequality of modern human society in terms of the changing geographical environment. Diamond believes that prehistoric people spread across continents were still small, mobile groups, collected by women and hunted by men. It was not until the Stone Age that the first farmers in the Middle East, who settled near water sources and began to grow and store food, showed that humans began to break the normal environmental cycle, choose individual plants to grow, and began to control and domesticate nature. However, the landscape varies from region to region, so the types of crops suitable for cultivation vary, as do the time and worker required to grow them, as well as the nutrients obtained from the crops, and the physical fitness of people in different regions gradually varies. Thus, the gap between the level of development of various regions of human society began to appear. In prehistoric (13,000 years ago), in the Middle East, for example, the local people made a living from hunting, when people were only small groups of mobility, collected by women, hunted by men, and people around the world survived in a similar state. With the change of climate, wild animals decrease and the area of wild grain growth gradually expands, so that human beings can get more grain in a short period of time. During the Stone Age (11,500 years ago), the Middle East was home to the world’s first farmers, who settled near water
downloadDownload free PDFView PDFchevron_right
Jared M. Diamond Guns, Germs and Steel
downloadDownload free PDFView PDFchevron_right
The Evolution and Development of Societies: The West and the Third World
Human history may be described and understood as the story of the change, evolution, development, and disappearance of human societies. Human societies across the vast expanse of human history go by different and various names: tribes, clans, chiefdoms, fiefdoms, kingdoms, empires and, currently, nation-states, which combine two disparate ideas: a cultural unit distinguished especially by a common language, and a territorial unit where sovereignty is exercised through power and coercion. Two issues appear: why is there such a diversity of 2 societies across the face of the earth, and why do societies diverge from each other as they develop over time.
downloadDownload free PDFView PDFchevron_right
Review of Chapter 9 from the Book ‘The Origins of Power, Prosperity, and Poverty: Why Nations Fail”
Putri Ayu Agita , 2024
This paper is a paper from the perspective of a group to understand the book “Why Nation Fail”. However, not only the paper, but readers will be presented with a discussion of material or understanding vocabulary that seems difficult to understand.
downloadDownload free PDFView PDFchevron_right
Essay-Review Writing the History of Development (Part 1: The First Wave
The rise of neoliberalism and the end of the Cold War ushered in a prolonged crisis of “development” as applied to the peoples of Africa, Asia and Latin America. Faced with impasse, historians and other social scientists set out on a novel journey to examine development as history. They proposed using history as the methodology for understanding development, rather than constructing development theories to explain history and model the future. In this first of a two-part article, some of the most important contributions to the “first wave” of writing the history of development are examined. Poststructuralist analysts were the first to lay out a genealogical framework, but they were soon followed by scholars in the field of U.S. diplomatic history who initiated a parallel investigation of the history of modernization. Much of the scholarship produced in the 1990s centered on the importance of discourse, particularly high policy statements, theories and ideologies. The concern with discourse shaped the new field in crucial ways: researchers fixed their attention on conceptual or intellectual frameworks, and perceived development from a Western and elitist perspective. Consequently, development’s totalizing claims and undifferentiated impact were accepted largely at face value. The limitations of this type of approach had become manifest by the end of the decade.
downloadDownload free PDFView PDFchevron_right
Economic Development Quarterly
downloadDownload free PDFView PDFchevron_right
Why nations fail: the origins of power, prosperity and poverty
Philippine Political Science Journal , 2014
downloadDownload free PDFView PDFchevron_right
Research in Human Ecology Diamond in the Rough: Reflections on Guns, Germs, and
2014
be one of the most important books published in the final decade of the last century. Winning numerous book awards, including the Pulitzer Prize, it has been translated into over two dozen languages, sold millions of copies worldwide, and has been the subject of a documentary produced by the National Geographic Society and broadcast on PBS. The broad appeal of GGS, as with Diamond’s previous book The Third Chimpanzee (1992) and his more recent book Collapse (2005), can be explained by its powerful and sweeping investigation into environmental history. Undeniably, few other scholarly works have been as comprehensive in scope and as prominent in public recognition. Here, for the 10th anniversary of the original publication of GGS, we review Diamond’s work, highlighting its major strengths, of which there are many, while also presenting
downloadDownload free PDFView PDFchevron_right
Related topics
HistoryaddFollowCultural StudiesaddFollowReligious HistoryaddFollow
- Explore
- Papers
- Topics
- Citation Generator
580 California St., Suite 400
San Francisco, CA, 94104
